I'm not being hard on the players.
I'm recognising how unprepared they must be, it being September, and how rare an opportunity it is for any NZ A level player - that I'm therefore disappointed that they're not being given a better opportunity to learn and succeed. Seeing as that's the whole point.
This will be over before they've got their bearings.
But as I conceded further up, that's actually a very realist blackcaps scenario.
But the gist of my point - the economics: It's expensive flying 15 players plus staff to India, etc etc , not sure who pays accomodation costs though. Therefore having made that investment, it seems false economy to go straight into tests, a FC game v local state side if available , or a non-FC game v a club side. Adding 4 days to the start of the tour at our own cost, arranging a FC game against one of the 27 state sides (preferably the local one where first test is played)
If it was a 3 match test series, I wouldn't be bothered as there's still time to learn at he back end of the series. Or if we were like England Lions and doing this all the time I wouldn't be worried, as someone will get more chances over several years.
But because we can't bat v spin, Sodhi and Astle don't get to bowl on a day 3/4 Indian wicket v sub continent batsmen. We've come all this way, paid all this money (someone has) to give it a half-arsed crack.
Edit.
Btw, the balance; 2 tests and 5 List A's. NZ cricket don't need to be making a finically investment in giving our A level players Indian List A experience. ODI caps are handed out like confetti, foreign T20 leagues etc. we have a large pool of players with white ball experience in Asian conditions. The gaping hole we need plugging is red ball cricket in Asian conditions.