• Welcome to the Cricket Web forums, one of the biggest forums in the world dedicated to cricket.

    You are currently viewing our boards as a guest which gives you limited access to view most discussions and access our other features. By joining our free community you will have access to post topics, respond to polls, upload content and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free so please, join the Cricket Web community today!

    If you have any problems with the registration process or your account login, please contact us.

Greatest Limited Overs All-rounder of all time, tournament/voting thread

mr_mister

mr_mister

Cricket Web: All-Time Legend
Well weldone has extended the two closest matches from 1 vote to 2 vote margins.

Couple that with the fact it's been over 12 hours since the last vote, I think it's high time we move onto Round 2!

Again I randomised the matches and will do again next round

Round 2:


Jacob Oram vs Imran Khan
Carl Hooper vs Andrew Flintoff
Shakib Al-Hasan vs Shane Watson
Andrew Symonds vs Jacques Kallis

Chris Harris vs Heath Streak
Lance Klusener vs Sanath Jayasuriya
Greg Chappell vs Viv Richards
Kapil Dev vs Abdul Razzaq
 
harsh.ag

harsh.ag

Cricket Web: All-Time Legend
Jacob Oram vs Imran Khan
Carl Hooper vs Andrew Flintoff
Shakib Al-Hasan vs Shane Watson
Andrew Symonds vs Jacques Kallis

Chris Harris vs Heath Streak
Lance Klusener vs Sanath Jayasuriya
Greg Chappell vs Viv Richards
Kapil Dev vs Abdul Razzaq
 
StephenZA

StephenZA

Hall of Fame Member
Jacob Oram vs Imran Khan
Carl Hooper vs Andrew Flintoff
Shakib Al-Hasan vs Shane Watson
Andrew Symonds vs Jacques Kallis

Chris Harris vs Heath Streak
Lance Klusener vs Sanath Jayasuriya
Greg Chappell vs Viv Richards
Kapil Dev vs Abdul Razzaq
 
watson

watson

Banned
Jacob Oram vs Imran Khan
Carl Hooper vs Andrew Flintoff
Shakib Al-Hasan vs Shane Watson
Andrew Symonds vs Jacques Kallis

Chris Harris vs Heath Streak
Lance Klusener vs Sanath Jayasuriya
Greg Chappell vs Viv Richards
Kapil Dev vs Abdul Razzaq
 
Red

Red

The normal awards that everyone else has
Jacob Oram vs Imran Khan
Carl Hooper vs Andrew Flintoff
Shakib Al-Hasan vs Shane Watson
Andrew Symonds vs Jacques Kallis

Chris Harris vs Heath Streak
Lance Klusener vs Sanath Jayasuriya
Greg Chappell vs Viv Richards
Kapil Dev vs Abdul Razzaq

Klusener v Sanath the hardest one here IMO. Not much separating Viv and Chappell as ARs either.
 
mr_mister

mr_mister

Cricket Web: All-Time Legend
Yeah Viv and Chappell's bowling ability and stats being quite similar make it hard. It basically comes down to their batting
 
weldone

weldone

Hall of Fame Member
Round 2:

Jacob Oram vs Imran Khan
Carl Hooper vs Andrew Flintoff
Shakib Al-Hasan vs Shane Watson
Andrew Symonds vs Jacques Kallis

Chris Harris vs Heath Streak
Lance Klusener vs Sanath Jayasuriya
Greg Chappell vs Viv Richards
Kapil Dev vs Abdul Razzaq
 
F

Fuller Pilch

Hall of Fame Member
Jacob Oram vs Imran Khan
Carl Hooper vs Andrew Flintoff
Shakib Al-Hasan vs Shane Watson
Andrew Symonds vs Jacques Kallis

Chris Harris vs Heath Streak
Lance Klusener vs Sanath Jayasuriya
Greg Chappell vs Viv Richards
Kapil Dev vs Abdul Razzaq
 
NUFAN

NUFAN

Y no Afghanistan flag
Round 2:

Imran Khan
Andrew Flintoff
Shane Watson
Andrew Symonds

Chris Harris
Sanath Jayasuriya
Abstain
Kapil Dev
 
watson

watson

Banned
Jayasuriyah:
13,432 runs at 32.36 with 28 hundreds. Strike Rate of 91.20.
323 wickets at 36.75. Economy Rate of 4.79
Player of the Series x 11 including 1995/96 ICC World Cup

Klusener:
3,576 runs at 41.10 with 2 hundreds. Strike Rate of 89.92
192 wickets at 29.95. Economy Rate of 4.70
Player of the Series x 4 including 1999 ICC World Cup
 
mr_mister

mr_mister

Cricket Web: All-Time Legend
watson said:
Jayasuriyah:
13,432 runs at 32.36 with 28 hundreds. Strike Rate of 91.20.
323 wickets at 36.75. Economy Rate of 4.79
Player of the Series x 11 including 1995/96 ICC World Cup

Klusener:
3,576 runs at 41.10 with 2 hundreds. Strike Rate of 89.92
192 wickets at 29.95. Economy Rate of 4.70
Player of the Series x 4 including 1999 ICC World Cup
Click to expand...
Well Sanath has the longevity... but Klusener wins the averages race comfortably.

I always find it really hard to rate top order batsman who bowl offies(even if its not 'part-time' and they usually get 10 overs a game) like Sanath and Carl Hooper as genuine, quality all-rounders. They don't feel like attacking off-spinners, just containers. God knows how Sanath got that many wickets
 
weldone

weldone

Hall of Fame Member
Any discussion on Sanath's bowling reminds me of 1996 World Cup semifinal at Eden Gardens, and that makes me sad.
 
jimmy101

jimmy101

Cricketer Of The Year
Jacob Oram vs Imran Khan
Carl Hooper vs Andrew Flintoff
Shakib Al-Hasan vs Shane Watson
Andrew Symonds vs Jacques Kallis

Chris Harris vs Heath Streak
Lance Klusener vs Sanath Jayasuriya
Greg Chappell vs Viv Richards
Kapil Dev vs Abdul Razzaq
 
jimmy101

jimmy101

Cricketer Of The Year
Toughest one for me this round was Symonds v Kallis. I'd rate Kallis' batting & bowling better overall, however, Symonds was a much more aggressive batsman & one of the greatest fielders (infield & outfield) I have seen, & so decided to vote for Symonds.

Even when suffering from hangovers, Symonds was the man for the job.
 
Noble One

Noble One

International Vice-Captain
Jacob Oram vs Imran Khan
Carl Hooper vs Andrew Flintoff
Shakib Al-Hasan vs Shane Watson
Andrew Symonds vs Jacques Kallis

Chris Harris vs Heath Streak
Lance Klusener vs Sanath Jayasuriya
Greg Chappell vs Viv Richards
Kapil Dev vs Abdul Razzaq
 
viriya

viriya

International Captain
Symonds was just not that effective as a bowler to be considered even close to kallis as an all-rounder. Hard to pick one solely as batsman either imo considering the dependable longevity of kallis.
 
smash84

smash84

The Tiger King
Imran Khan
Andrew Flintoff
Shane Watson
Kallis

Chris Harris
Sanath Jayasuriya
Viv Richards
Kapil Dev
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Top