Cricketweb decides the best fielder ever

[Fuller Pilch]

I'm actually amazed no-one's nominated Michael Clarke yet. He was an incredible fielder in his younger days.

Ponting
ABdV
Symonds
Clarke
Herschelle Gibbs
James Anderson (reckon he's the best fielder out of any fast bowler I've seen)
Flintoff (brilliant at slip, rocket arm from the outfield)
Guptill

Will have a think about the other 2.

Do you really think think that James Anderson is a better fielder than Chris Jordan and Boult/Southee?

 

[Victor Ian]

Andrew Symonds
Andrew Symonds - yes - he was really that good
Andrew Symonds - seriously
Mark Waugh
Ricky Ponting
Alan Border
Jonty Rhodes
Clive Lloyd
Viv Richards
Roger Harper

 

[Chrish]

Johnty
Gibbs
Abdv
Faf
Punter

Fielding has been hallmark of Saffas

 

[Victor Ian]

i don't think people will agree with me and they can all go suck it. Facts are Symonds was the most best amazing best superman greatest awesome bradman-level-better fielder ever. When he played, I was waiting for the Australia Batting to get out, not to watch them bowl but to watch Symonds field.

 

[Furball]

Do you really think think that James Anderson is a better fielder than Chris Jordan and Boult/Southee?

lol

 

[mr_mister]

Mark Waugh
Mark Taylor
Graeme Hick
Jonty
Ab
Wally Hammond
Ponting
Steve Smith

 

[watson]

As an allround fielder standing anywhere you care to mention it has to be Roger Harper;

 

[Red]

Ones I've seen (this'll be a bit Australia centric)-

Best slips: Taylor, Mark Waugh, Ponting

Inner ring fielders: Symonds, Viv Richards, Ponting, Rhodes, Clive Lloyd, Harper, early Clarke, early Allan Border

Overall, Mark Waugh in the slips and Symonds in the inner ring.

 

[kingkallis]

Jonty Rhodes
AB de Villiers
Ricky Ponting
Herschelle Gibbs
Andrew Symonds
Hansie Cronje
Mohammad Azharuddin
Paul Collingwood
Mark Waugh
David Warner

 

[HeathDavisSpeed]

On the subs bench:

Trevor Penney
Peter Cantrell
Gary Pratt

Was going to mention Penney. Terrific fielder. Deserves to be in the mix here, even though he didn't (really) play internationals. His fielding was definitely world class, and no surprise that he became a fielding coach.

 

[Hurricane]

Guptill
Gus Logie
DeVilliers
Faff
Coney
Botham
Randall
McDermott (purely for his arm)
Harris
Garner (also for his arm)

 

[G.I.Joe]

Qualified	Need 1 more vote to qualify	Nominated once so far	Nominated once so far
Ricky Ponting A.B. de Villiers Clive Lloyd Herchelle Gibbs Andrew Symonds Paul Collingood Mark Waugh Jonty Rhodes Roger Harper Dave Warner Bobby Simpson Colin Bland Eknath Solkar Tillakaratne Dilshan Garry Sobers Viv Richards Martin Guptill Learie Constantine	Mohammad Azharuddin Derek Randall Steven Smith Allan Border Chris Harris Faf duPlessis Munaf Patel	EM Grace Gilbert Jessop Gary Pratt Derek Randall Greg Chappell Kapil Dev Ian Bell Brian Lara Chris Jordan Roshan Mahanama Kane Williamson Michael Hussey Dwayne Leverock Marcus Trescothick Trevor Penney Peter Cantrell	Hansie Cronje Graeme Hick Mark Taylor Joel Garner Ian Botham Gus Logie Craig McDermott Wally Hammond Jeremy Coney Glenn Maxwell Jacques Kallis Ajinkya Rahane Michael Clarke James Anderson Andrew Flintoff

 

[cnerd123]

Learie Constantine needs to get into the final 32,

 

[Hurricane]

Randall listed twice?

 

[Daemon]

Second Munaf

 

[viriya]

Considering the fact that Mahanama was a better fielder than Dilshan, it wouldn't make sense that Dilshan gets picked and not Mahanama.

 

[G.I.Joe]

Randall listed twice?

Good spot. Moved to second column.

 

[cnerd123]

You've got Constantine there twice too.

Get your **** together Joe

 

[G.I.Joe]

You've got Constantine there twice too.

Get your **** together Joe

Whatcha talking about?

 

[The Sean]

Neil Harvey
Norman O'Neill
Jack Gregory
Joe Solomon
Keith Miller
Percy Chapman
Frank Woolley
David Boon