Historical Discussion- Best batting all-rounders after Sobers and Kallis

[Adorable Asshole]

Sobers
Imran
Kallis
Botham
Miller
Kapil
Stokes
Cairns
T Greig
Shakib
Jadeja
Flintoff
Vettori

Miller is a better all-rounder than Botham and Kallis

 

[Majestic]

Miller is a better all-rounder than Botham and Kallis

Miller is overrated. Played in an era where opposition was only England, West Indies and a couple of other minnows.

 

[Adorable Asshole]

Miller is overrated. Played in an era where opposition was only England, West Indies and a couple of other minnows.

That also applies to Sobers, Bradman and other old timers.

 

[Silver Line]

Allen Hill 50 bat avg and 18 bwl avg

 

[Silver Line]

Mick Malone 46 bat avg 14 bwl avg

 

[Silver Line]

Saqib Mahmood 52 bat avg 22 bwl avg…. wait hang on

 

[Majestic]

That also applies to Sobers, Bradman and other old timers.

If anyone in modern era averages 90, he would be better than Bradman in Tests. There has simply been no one that far ahead so can't disregard the fact that he was way ahead of his time.

Sobers played in 60s and is widely regarded as the best ever A/R. Miller is great no doubt but just purely on stats, can't rate him above Botham or Kallis.

 

[shortpitched713]

If anyone in modern era averages 90, he would be better than Bradman in Tests.

Unfortunately we'll never find out, as Indian selectors refuse to pick Sarfaraz Khan.