kingkallis
International Coach
50 ODIs is fair number and I also think 6 hours is sufficient time to pick your player...
Sorry mate, but the thing is ultimately the player's reputation will have a big say. One side has a good team with proper balance while the other side has lets say, Gary Sobers who is probably amongst the top three cricketers of all time. Even though, Sobers played only one ODI and didn't do that well, his name will be difficult to ignore. I hope you understand it. Cheers.Will play if you remove the 50 ODIs limit
You're free to not rate players with fewer caps when it comes to the vote, surely
But we'll be rating the players based on their ODI exploits. I think everyone here is smart enough to see Sobers in an all time ODI line up and not judge him and his role in the team based on his test exploits.Sorry mate, but the thing is ultimately the player's reputation will have a big say. One side has a good team with proper balance while the other side has lets say, Gary Sobers who is probably amongst the top three cricketers of all time. Even though, Sobers played only one ODI and didn't do that well, his name will be difficult to ignore. I hope you understand it. Cheers.
Hmmmm.But we'll be rating the players based on their ODI exploits. I think everyone here is smart enough to see Sobers in an all time ODI line up and not judge him and his role in the team based on his test exploits.
I understand the potential problem you have, but I think people will be sensible and view Sobers for the ODI player he was, and therefore not rate him very highly.
No, mate. Its ok.I'll stay out then, as we're oversubscribed.
FixedI see this 6 hour thing lasting all of four picks before it is changed to 24 hours.
awtaBut we'll be rating the players based on their ODI exploits. I think everyone here is smart enough to see Sobers in an all time ODI line up and not judge him and his role in the team based on his test exploits.
I understand the potential problem you have, but I think people will be sensible and view Sobers for the ODI player he was, and therefore not rate him very highly.