CW Draft League

[Monk]

Originally Posted by Marcuss

1. Geoff Boycott
2.
3.
4. Javed Miandad
5. Steve Waugh
6. Adam Gilchrist
7. Aubrey Faulkner (5)
8. Ian Botham (3)
9.
10. Bill O'Reilly (4)
11. Ian Bishop (1)

FWIW, even though your day sucked, your draft team is beginning to look imposing. Bowling attack shaping up very nicely. Love a team that contains two genuine spin options.

[Jager]

R1
kingkallis- Garfield Sobers
Himannv- Imran Khan
Marcuss- Adam Gilchrist
Cabinet96- Keith Miller
Eds- Malcolm Marshall
Cevno- Richard Hadlee
Blakus- Vivian Richards
MrPrez- Jaques Kallis
watson- Glenn McGrath
Jager- Curtly Ambrose
AndyZaltzHair- Dennis Lillee
kyear2- Jack Hobbs

R2
kyear2- Shane Warne
AndyZaltzHair- Fred Trueman
Jager- Sachin Tendulkar
watson- Michael Holding
MrPrez- Muttiah Muralitharan
Blakus- Sydney Barnes
Cevno- Wasim Akram
Eds- Brian Lara
Cabinet96- Len Hutton
Marcuss- Bill O'Reilly
Himannv- Alan Davidson
kingkallis- Wally Hammond

R3
Jager- Waqar Younis
kyear2- Allan Donald
Himannv- George Headley
AndyZaltzHair- Ray Lindwall
Eds- Joel Garner
Marcuss- Aubrey Faulkner
kingkallis- Dale Steyn
Blakus- Graeme Pollock
Cabinet96- Clyde Walcott
Cevno- Shaun Pollock
MrPrez- Mike Procter
watson- Andy Roberts

R4
watson- Greg Chappell
MrPrez- Victor Trumper
Cevno- Andrew Flower
Cabinet96- Jim Laker
Blakus- Sunil Gavaskar
kingkallis- Richie Benaud
Marcuss- Ian Botham
Eds- Barry Richards
AndyZaltzHair- Clarrie Grimmett
Himannv- Frank Tyson
kyear2- Ricky Ponting
Jager- Harold Larwood

R5
AndyZaltzHair- Les Ames
kyear2- Everton Weekes
Blakus- Herbert Sutcliffe
Jager- Neil Harvey
Cabinet96- Courtney Walsh
Marcuss- Steve Waugh
Cevno- WG Grace
MrPrez- Allan Border
watson- Alan Knott
kingkallis- Rahul Dravid
Himannv- Ken Barrington
Eds- Kapil Dev

R6
Eds- Frank Worrell
Himannv- Denis Compton
kingkallis- Matthew Hayden
watson- Hedley Verity
MrPrez- Ian Healy
Cevno- Anil Kumble
Marcuss- Javed Miandad
Cabinet96- Fazal Mahmood
Jager- Wilfred Rhodes
Blakus- Kumar Sangakkara
kyear2- Denis Lindsay
AndyZaltzHair- Arthur Morris

R7
watson- Bob Simpson
Jager- Dudley Nourse
AndyZaltzHair- Clive Lloyd
Eds- Gordon Greenidge
kingkallis- Graham Gooch
Marcuss- Geoff Boycott
kyear2- Colin Croft
Himannv- Hanif Mohammad
MrPrez- Saqlain Mushtaq
Blakus- Frederick Spofforth
Cevno- Virender Sehwag
Cabinet96- Bruce Mitchell

R8
Cabinet96- Shivnarine Chanderpaul
Cevno- Shane Bond
Blakus- Peter Pollock
MrPrez- Bob Willis
Himannv- Bill Lawry
kyear2- Ted Dexter
Marcuss- Ian Bishop
kingkallis-
Eds- Charles Macartney
AndyZaltzHair- Bill Ponsford
Jager- Alec Stewart
watson-

R9
Cabinet96-
Cevno-
Eds-
AndyZaltzHair-
Marcuss-
Jager-
MrPrez-
kingkallis-
watson-
Blakus-
Himannv-
kyear2-

R10
kyear2-
Himannv-
Blakus-
watson-
kingkallis-
MrPrez-
Jager-
Marcuss-
AndyZaltzHair-
Eds-
Cevno-
Cabinet96-

R11
AndyZaltzHair-
Jager-
MrPrez-
Marcuss-
Blakus-
Himannv-
kyear2-
Eds-
kingkallis-
watson-
Cevno-
Cabinet96-

R12
Cabinet96-
Cevno-
watson-
kingkallis-
Eds-
kyear2-
Himannv-
Blakus-
Marcuss-
MrPrez-
Jager-
AndyZaltzHair-

[watson]

Originally Posted by Jager

I think 12 would probably be way more efficent and prevent the draft from dragging on, which is unfortunate because some excellent drafters will miss out on the first round.

So, on how big the relegation zone should be. Instinct says two, which would mean morgieb and Monk gain promotion at the end of the round and the bottom two vote pollers exit the league until they are in line to re-enter. This adds pressure to the draft, as in future rounds even the championship leader may be relegated for a round after a disaster of a draft.

We have six points-scoring positions (1-6), four neutral mid-table positions (7-10) and two demotion positions (11-12).

First draft rules
ATG test draft, players must have played at least one test match.
No Bradman.
There is a 12 hour selection zone before you are skipped. You still choose at any time, but the draft continues and you may miss out on players.
We will have twelve rounds. Your 12th pick does not have to be your 12th man.
A new thread will go up on Cricket Chat where everyone votes on three different teams, which is how we will determine the winners, point-scorers etc.

Order

R1
kingkallis
Himannv
Marcuss
Cabinet96
Eds
Cevno
Blakus
MrPrez
watson
Jager
AndyZaltzHair
kyear2

R2
kyear2
AndyZaltzHair
Jager
watson
MrPrez
Blakus
Cevno
Eds
Cabinet96
Marcuss
Himannv
kingkallis

Alright, the draft league is on.

Just had a thought (yeah yeah, a rarity I know). What happens if there are more than 2 teams tied for demotion? It is possible that 3 or more teams might all be stuck on zero points, or 1 point, or whatever.

Not sure what to suggest though. However, we don't want to get into the situation where everyone has to vote for their 2 worst teams. It could get acrimonous.

Perhaps we could just say that 2 teams are demoted when possible, but if there happen to be more than 2 teams tied on points (or no points) then those teams (3 or more) all get demoted?

I think that a specific time frame for voting is also advisable. Say, 1 week. Otherwise when do you know to declare the winners/losers since the whole of Cricketweb is voting?

Or, it is compulsory for all participants in the Draft League AND the Reserve Draft League to vote, but the voting is still left open for a week so that other interested Cricketweb people can vote as well.

But now I'm starting to crap on........

[Eds]

Think that's KK's 12 hours up.

1. Barry Richards
2. Gordon Greenidge
3. Charlie Macartney
4. Brian Lara
5. -
6. Frank Worrell
7. -
8. Kapil Dev
9. Malcolm Marshall
10. Joel Garner
11. -

[AndyZaltzHair]

Bill Ponsford

[Jager]

Gutted Macartney got snatched from me! Good pick Eds. Ponny also a great selection, he was a colossus. Watson, I have been struggling to figure out the voting too - what happens in the third and fourth 'seasons' of the Draft League? Will people start strategically voting for other competitors in order to give themselves an advantage? I would hope that we all agree on an honour code - we all vote on who we genuinely believe are the three best sides. Anyone can vote though, seeing as a large majority of CW drafters are involved in the League and the Reserves.

[AndyZaltzHair]

For three/four teams sitting with same amount of votes, then tie breaker voting can be done between only those teams; there can be better solution though

[Jager]

Oh and I choose Alec Stewart, after much consideration. I will play him as an opener though, where he had all of his success. He averaged 45 as an opening batsman and became a very reliable gloveman as his career progressed.

1. Alec Stewart+
2.
3. Neil Harvey
4. Sachin Tendulkar
5. Dudley Nourse
6.
7.
8. Wilfred Rhodes
9. Harold Larwood
10. Curtly Ambrose
11. Waqar Younis

[watson]

I'm optimistic. People like seeing great cricket teams and will therefore vote for them. That's why we come here.

[AndyZaltzHair]

Ah master class move by Jager

[watson]

Rohan Kanhai at this point in the draft is as obvious as an obvious thing for the No.3 spot because Chappell and Kanhai batting together would be superb to watch. Chappell working the ball to the onside boundary off his pads, and Kanhai stroking it through the covers for 4.

1.Bob Simpson
2.
3.Rohan Kanhai
4.Greg Chappell
5.
6
7.Alan Knott
8.Hedley Verity
9.Andy Roberts
10.Michael Holding
11.Glen McGrath

[watson]

Originally Posted by Jager

Oh and I choose Alec Stewart, after much consideration. I will play him as an opener though, where he had all of his success. He averaged 45 as an opening batsman and became a very reliable gloveman as his career progressed.

1. Alec Stewart+
2.
3. Neil Harvey
4. Sachin Tendulkar
5. Dudley Nourse
6.
7.
8. Wilfred Rhodes
9. Harold Larwood
10. Curtly Ambrose
11. Waqar Younis

Stewart will need at least 10 weetbix for breaky if he's combining opening and keeping duties.

However, I'm really interested to see who you will pick as your batting allrounder for the No.7 spot Jager. But I won't guess out loud.......

[Eds]

Some really good teams beginning to form here. Good to see. Jager's team really starting to look one of the classier.

On that note, delighted with the way my team has taken shape. I firmly believe it would have been absolutely fantastic to watch if nothing else.

[Jager]

Originally Posted by Eds

1. Barry Richards
2. Gordon Greenidge
3. Charlie Macartney
4. Brian Lara

That top four would be enthralling to watch. The majesty of Richards, the raw aggression of Greenidge, the talent of Lara and of course the governor general... one of my all time favourites. I wish I could find footage of him batting.

[watson]

Originally Posted by Jager

That top four would be enthralling to watch. The majesty of Richards, the raw aggression of Greenidge, the talent of Lara and of course the governor general... one of my all time favourites. I wish I could find footage of him batting.

The main question is, who will out-score who?

And which bowler will I put on to contain Richards and Macartney if the pair 'get-going' similtaneously?