Vaughan got it and he has a poor ODI record. Ed Smith could be a contendor even if he doesnt even play for England.
Ed Smith could well have a shot - he's been setting a phenomonal pace in county cricket.
Traditionally there would probably be two players for their performances in English county cricket (E Smith), two players for their performances in the English international summer (G Smith) and one other for outstanding performances worldwide (Ponting).
Vaughan got it because he had the second best calender year in the history of test cricket.
My house is burned down but I can see the sky.
Was looking for a Ponting fielding thread to dig, or something to do with his history, but couldn't find one. So this will do...
Do you think that Ponting's fielding in the slips has hurt his legacy as a fielder? He was absolute dynamite back in his prime, and used to be mentioned in the same breath as Rhodes for a while, due to his propensity to hit the stumps so often. But as a slipper, where he spends most of his time in Tests these days, I'd describe him as enigmatic at best.
In ODIs in the field he still looks dynamic tbh only AB can test in the world now that Symo is gone. So overall i'd say no.
"I am very happy and it will allow me to have lot more rice."
Eoin Morgan on being given a rice cooker for being Man of the Match in a Dhaka Premier Division game.
One of the catches they are using for a promotion on the local TV coverage features a Ponting catch from last summer against Souht Africa. He is diving sideways from second slip completely outstretched mid air taking a absolute blinder.
Out of the top batsmen in the last 20 years Ponting would be far and away the best fielder.
Overall yeah. Not as a slip tho.
GOOD OLD COLLINGWOOD - PREMIERS IN 2010Originally Posted by Irfan
Is Cam White, Is Good.
Agree he's overall a good slip who has flashes of brilliance but drops a few too many. You were saying 'far and away the best' however which I would agree with re overall fielding bit not specifically re slips. Dravid, Hayden, and depending on your definition of 'top batsman' Mark Waugh and Mark Taylor all have him well covered in the slips just off the top of my head.
I would accept less blinders if it meant a corresponding increase in regulation chances taken. He does drop some of the most basic grabs at slip, and that places him below the very best.
Always has a knack of pulling off a stunning and crucial run out or two every time he plays India in an ODI series. He's great to watch in the field.
Symonds and Rhodes were his only peers as an overall ring fielder IMO
I've seen Ponting do the same. He hasn't ended up with the records for catches because he's an average slipper.
There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)