silentstriker
The Wheel is Forever
ICC gives umpire reviews the go-ahead | Cricket News | Cricinfo ICC Site | Cricinfo.com
A couple other good developments in there too.
A couple other good developments in there too.
I'm not. Hopefully it'll be abandoned once everyone's got to realise what a terrible idea it is.This will be good if common sense is applied. I'm sure it will be okay once everyone's got used to it.
Evidence so far suggests the truth of this is debateable TSTL, and that even if it were slightly true (which it's absolutely no more than) that the backlash is considerable - and that's without the facet that was the most immediate and obvious (potential to undermine Umpiring authority).Errors in decision-making will be reduced.
you are a regular contrarian on this board arent you.Be so much easier to just use a better system rather than trying to push water uphill to make a nonsensical system work.
I don't see how allowing obvious umpiring errors (which are of course apparent to everyone) to stand uncorrected undermines umpires.Evidence so far suggests the truth of this is debateable TSTL, and that even if it were slightly true (which it's absolutely no more than) that the backlash is considerable - and that's without the facet that was the most immediate and obvious (potential to undermine Umpiring authority).
There are, in my view, plenty of arguments against the review system and precious few (now we actually know what it entails) in its favour.
Common sense initiatives all.ICC gives umpire reviews the go-ahead | Cricket News | Cricinfo ICC Site | Cricinfo.com
A couple other good developments in there too.
West Indies played at least a couple of series' under the trial. Therefore, you should know why.What's nonsensical about it?