The Slate is wiped clean , who would you like to see in Englands ODI squad

[Perm]

Originally Posted by Prince EWS

Similiarly, when someone with Trott's record gets picked in the ODI squad but doesn't play a game because ot Twenty20 failures, then slips down the pecking order behind someone who has gone from a nothing allrounder to a opening batsman in one season, you have even more problems.

Sure do. Trott may not be ready for ODI cricket, but how on earth Luke Wright moved above him in the pecking-order is beyond me.

[Richard]

Originally Posted by Prince EWS

Similiarly, when someone with Trott's record gets picked in the ODI squad but doesn't play a game because ot Twenty20 failures, then slips down the pecking order behind someone who has gone from a nothing allrounder to a opening batsman in one season, you have even more problems.

At least they were picked for totally different roles, but it's ridiculous nonetheless, though I didn't follow Trott's OD fortunes in 2007, and if he wasn't performing, I'm glad he wasn't picked for ODIs, as there's little worse than a good player in bad form making his ODI debut.

[iamdavid]

Originally Posted by superwills

keep kirtley mahmood hoggard bresnan and tremlett away from the odi team. Ali cook out too -scores too slowly. mustard 200% in for prior. tresco in if fit. maybe benning but he needs more cc matches 1st. mascarenhas must be in. vaughan and strauss away! monty in but keep eye on graham swann and rashid although i have not seen him bowl in od cricket. Im still out on luke wright...
MY ENGLAND ODI XI:
1. Tresco
2.Mustard
3.Bell
4.Pietersen
5.Collingwood
6.Flintoff
7.Mascarenhas
8.Swann
9.Broad
10.Sidebottom
11.Anderson

12. Bopara(unlucky)

Hopefully you just forgot about Owais Shah rather than leaving him out on merit, seems ready to take his game to the next level to me. Very dependable and adaptable player, given his recent form continues then England will atleast have a very solid middle order to build around with Pieterson, Collingwood and Shah.

[sunilreddy]

Trescothick
Cook
Bell
Pieterson
Collingwood(C)
Bopara
Wright
Mascheranus
Anderson
Tremlett
Panesar
Benning
Mustard(wk)
Broad
Swann