• Welcome to the Cricket Web forums, one of the biggest forums in the world dedicated to cricket.

    You are currently viewing our boards as a guest which gives you limited access to view most discussions and access our other features. By joining our free community you will have access to post topics, respond to polls, upload content and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free so please, join the Cricket Web community today!

    If you have any problems with the registration process or your account login, please contact us.

Afridi back, where should he play?

mohammad16

U19 Captain
Most people want him to play at 6.7 basically down the order

I dont think thats the best position for him at all, maybe on english and australian pitches, but not in sub continent

he needs to open on the sub continent pitches or come 1 down if there is considerable movement early on

especially when chasing, he needs to open, there have been numerous situations most notably againts india in india, where pakistan were chasing lost wickets, needed alot of runs of the last 15 or so overs, but afridi simply seemed useless at that spot

if he had opened, right from the get go, you would think he could quickly change the match in the favour of pakistan
he seems to make a much greater impact when he opens and gives paksitan a good start

feild restrictions also play a big role, afridi most of the time tries to hit the ball out of the ground, doenst really worry too much about placement, this is really suited to the first 15 overs of gameplay

with teh field spread out, afridi has had minimal success, ofcourse we can refer to the 50 of 20 odd balls he made againts australia in australia, but pakistan still ended up loosing that game.

I dont think its the worst desicion in the world to play him lower down the order, if they are obviously tempted, i think they should do the following

always look to play afridi within the fielding restrictions when ever pakistan CHASES
maybe send him lower down the order when pakistan bats first
 

Merv

Banned
I've always thought he should open.

Even though he fails quite a lot here, surely it makes sense with his style and the first 10 overs restrictions. He has more chance of getting away with it, on paper.

If not there then 7.
 

Perm

Cricket Web: All-Time Legend
To be honest I can't see him being a better play than any of the current Pakistan lineup with perhaps the exception of Mohammad Hafeez, who is still young and learning and who I think has a very big future ahead of him. If he was to come straight back into the side, it probably would be to open with either Imran Farhat, Mohammad Hafeez or Shoaib Malik.
 

Matt79

Global Moderator
More power to him if he does - he's fun to watch when he's going, I just think the players already in the team are better than him at present.
 

nightprowler10

Global Moderator
Matt79 said:
More power to him if he does - he's fun to watch when he's going, I just think the players already in the team are better than him at present.
With Younis, Yousuf and Inzamam out of the next ODI, his inclusion can perhaps be justified?
 

nightprowler10

Global Moderator
We're up 2-0 with still 2 matches to go, so not quite wrapped up as far as I'm concerned. One could argue that he brings some experience in to the team, however, seeing as how he is coming in to the team as pure batsman, you could say there are better choices out there.
 

shortpitched713

International Captain
Beleg said:
*sigh*

Afridi should be NO WHERE NEAR the team.
On what basis?

He clearly has the capability to be destructive with both the ball and the bat, his domestic form with the ball is excellent, and he just got a 90 ball hundred as well. I think he deserves a shot just as much as any other player who is performing well.
 

haroon510

International 12th Man
number 6 or 7 since that is when it is needed for him to score fast and play big shots.

i also think that for this match they should pick yasir hameed in place of hafiz. hafiz is a test player not a one day and i think his strike rate proves this.
open with yasir and farhat and then in one down they should send malik who really plays good in this position. i think the team should look this way.

farhat
hameed
malik
faisal
razzaq
kamran
afridi
rahman
naved
sami ( in place of rao)
gul
 

Beleg

International Regular
On what basis?

He clearly has the capability to be destructive with both the ball and the bat, his domestic form with the ball is excellent, and he just got a 90 ball hundred as well. I think he deserves a shot just as much as any other player who is performing well.
The difference between other performing players and him is that he has been tried, tested, given the chance on more occasions then any other batsman in the history of the game and he still hasn't utilized it anywhere close to his alleged 'potential.' He's a failure, as simple as that.

The only reason he is still in the frame is because of his glamourous, crowd-pulling nature.
 

aussie

Hall of Fame Member
Beleg said:
*sigh*

Afridi should be NO WHERE NEAR the team.
no way, he's been very consistent since the VB series 2005 up until the ODI series in England, he just went through a bad patch. In this WC season along with the return of Shoaib/Asif to the ranks, Afridi is a bloke the selectors should be backing.
 

shortpitched713

International Captain
Beleg said:
The difference between other performing players and him is that he has been tried, tested, given the chance on more occasions then any other batsman in the history of the game and he still hasn't utilized it anywhere close to his alleged 'potential.' He's a failure, as simple as that.

The only reason he is still in the frame is because of his glamourous, crowd-pulling nature.
Ridiculous to compare him to other batsmen, as he is an allrounder whos bowling clearly plays a part in his selection. If we had to pick players based on their batting or bowling alone then we could forget about ever selecting Razzaq or Malik either. Our allrounders are one of our main strengths in our ODI and to a lesser extent our Test side. The were very useful because they could do almost if not as well of a job with the bat or ball as most specialists that were available. Just because Afridi hasn't been fulfilling the role of a specialist with the bat doesn't mean we should write him off.
 

Top