-
Welcome to the Cricket Web forums, one of the biggest forums in the world dedicated to cricket.
You are currently viewing our boards as a guest which gives you limited access to view most discussions and access our other features. By joining our free community you will have access to post topics, respond to polls, upload content and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free so please, join the Cricket Web community today!
If you have any problems with the registration process or your account login, please contact us.
BREAKING NEWS:::: SHOIAB and ASIF ban Lifted!!!!!!
- Thread starter Bouncer
- Start date
Bouncer
State Regular
Perm
Cricket Web: All-Time Legend
Utterly ridiculous in my opinion, they did the crime and so they should do the time. Shane Warne "claimed" he didn't know he has taking illegal drugs and he got banned, why is it different for these two? The Pakistan Cricket Board are "corrupt" for want of a better word, saw it coming though because there was no way they would've deprived Pakistan of their two best bowlers.
Bouncer
State Regular
Perm said:
Agree with you partially on this being a bad decision.
But Decision was made by a saperate tribunal bot by PCB, and cant be compared with Warne as i am unaware as if Wanrne appealed against his case, as these guys did appeal after the first punishment was announced!
I persoanlly would hve loved to see Shoaib out...............but i dont mind seeing him back either, I Know its confusing, Sorry!!!
honestbharani
Whatever it takes!!!
well, this is worse than how Warney got away.
Slow Love™
International Captain
I half expected the appeals to be successful, though I thought it would be on the basis of the PCB not adhering to the prescribed method viz-a-viz their testing procedure. Is that the defence that has been accepted? The BBC article kinda implies the tribunal might have accepted the defence that they didn't know they were taking these substances... Which seems a bit ridiculous, particularly in Akhtar's case.
I think the PCB screwed themselves in trying to deal with this themselves, out of fear perhaps that the ICC would be even harsher on the players concerned.
I think the PCB screwed themselves in trying to deal with this themselves, out of fear perhaps that the ICC would be even harsher on the players concerned.
Bouncer
State Regular
If You belived it, Then Why in the freaking hell you did not tell usDravid said:
all when this whole saga started? If i belive you for a Minute, then you probably also know the result of upcoming SA Inda Test series, Would you like to share that now or come back at end of the series and tell us that you knew what was happening before the first test!
shortpitched713
International Captain
Total farce. Excuse me while I clean the vomit out of my mouth.
mohammad16
U19 Captain
WOW I AM SO HAPPY I CANT describe, the levels of that drug in shoaib were in significant, this is just great for pakistan cricket, now it reall boosts thier cahnces in the world cup
shoaib is the most entertaining bowler in cricket and really what sad way it woudl have been to leave
i am confident these guys didnt take any drugs to actually increase thier performance
if the drugs were taken to heal quicker, i think the alloted punishment was a bit too hard, i mean players are able to get away with alot of other thigs in sport, and its not liek shoaibs been bowling consistnetly over 100 mph
ALso i expected this aswell, however ididnt they think they would actually get banned and then have thier sentences over turned, i felft that pcb would make noise by assusing them, and when i heard that pcb was in charge of the investigation, i knew that there was a big chance shoaib and asif would get off the hook.
jus great for cricket
shoaib is the most entertaining bowler in cricket and really what sad way it woudl have been to leave
i am confident these guys didnt take any drugs to actually increase thier performance
if the drugs were taken to heal quicker, i think the alloted punishment was a bit too hard, i mean players are able to get away with alot of other thigs in sport, and its not liek shoaibs been bowling consistnetly over 100 mph
ALso i expected this aswell, however ididnt they think they would actually get banned and then have thier sentences over turned, i felft that pcb would make noise by assusing them, and when i heard that pcb was in charge of the investigation, i knew that there was a big chance shoaib and asif would get off the hook.
jus great for cricket
Dravid
International Captain
Erm, what? Did I say I know for sure, or I knew that when the ban was placed?Bouncer said:If You belived it, Then Why in the freaking hell you did not tell us
If i belive you for a Minute, then you probably also know the result of upcoming SA Inda Test series, Would you like to share that now or come back at end of the series and tell us that you knew what was happening before the first test!
marc71178
Eyes not spreadsheets
Why exactly would that mean there should be a distinction?mohammad16 said:
It's cheating either way, and in fact one could argue that by taking them to ensure they get back on the field sooner they are performance enhancing.
I'd strongly disagree with that.mohammad16 said:
shortpitched713
International Captain
I don't even know how to answer that. Just pathetic. The guys did the crime, it doesn't matter for what reason they did it, they should be punished. Extenuating circumstances would only come in to play in lightening the sentence, not letting them off alltogether. I don't even know why yet they've been let of, but its probably some bs excuse from the PCB. I hope Shoaib Akhtar gets injured. Would be poetic justice for mine.mohammad16 said:
mohammad16
U19 Captain
well maybe im being too lenient but i think, the punishment is harsh even if its 3 months or 2 years
ur labelled a cheat for life, i mean imagine how the public would deal with u for the rest of ur life, its alot for someithing they possibly didnt even take
all im saiying is that, theres a strong possibilty the substance wasnt taken on purpose, and the talk about cricketers should know exactly whats going in is complete BULL, there is no cricketer in the world who monitors his diet from ingredient to ingredient, u got so called experts around u who should be hled more resposible
ur labelled a cheat for life, i mean imagine how the public would deal with u for the rest of ur life, its alot for someithing they possibly didnt even take
all im saiying is that, theres a strong possibilty the substance wasnt taken on purpose, and the talk about cricketers should know exactly whats going in is complete BULL, there is no cricketer in the world who monitors his diet from ingredient to ingredient, u got so called experts around u who should be hled more resposible