Flintoff v/s other all-rounders (ODI figures)

[bagapath]

flintoff should be my choice for an all time one day XI as an allrounder.

First XI

tendulkar
gilchrist (wk)
richards
kallis
jones
bevan
flintoff
akram
murali
garner
mcgrath

Second XI

ganguly
jayasuriya
ponting
lara
inzy
sangakkara (wk)
klusener
imran
saqlain
waqar
donald

EDIT: Perm! Thanks for pointing out the most horrendous error anyone can ever make in selecting a oneday team!!! I've corrected it.

 

[Perm]

No Michael Bevan? I don't think Flintoff would be the main all rounder in an All Time ODI XI to be perfectly honest.

 

[FaaipDeOiad]

Kluesener at his peak was a better ODI all-rounder, and there's a few others like Kapil who would have a good shout. Flintoff has a way to go I think.

 

[oz_fan]

flintoff should be my choice for an all time one day XI as an allrounder.

tendulkar
gilchrist (wk)
richards
lara/ponting
kallis
jones
flintoff
akram
murali
garner
mcgrath

12th man: Waqar

I would have a similar side to that except I would have Jones at 5 with Bevan at 6 and leave out Kallis. I'd also take either Shaun Pollock, Lance Klusener, Imran Khan or Kapil Dev for the all rounder spot ahead of Flintoff.

 

[bagapath]

Kluesener at his peak was a better ODI all-rounder, and there's a few others like Kapil who would have a good shout. Flintoff has a way to go I think.

kapil's batting was a huge let down in one dayers.

225 198 39 3783 175* 23.79 1 14