Players Grading

[Xuhaib]

Just putting on a teachers hat and grading players on their overall skill and potential.

Pakistan

Farhat (B)
Butt (C) potential B+
Hafeez (B)
Younis (A)
Yousuf (A)
Inzi (A)
Faisal (C)
Taufeeq (D)
Akmal (B+) potential A
Afridi and Razzaq (A) in Odi's (C) in tests
Malik (B+)
Shoaib (A)
Asif (A) potential A*
Gul (B) potential A
Rana (B)
Sami (U)
Raza (D) potential A
Hameed (C) potential B
Kaneria (B+) potential A

[Langeveldt]

Rikki Clarke - Q

[superkingdave]

Tresco - C
Strauss - C
Cook - C potential B
KP - C potential B
Collingwood E
Bell - D potential C
Read - D
Mahmood - F potential D
Hoggard - C
Harmison - D most of the time, ocassionaly B
Panesar - D potential C

Flintoff - B/A
Vaughan - C
Jones - D potential B
Plunkett - F potential E
Giles - D

[Xuhaib]

Originally Posted by superkingdave

Tresco - C
Strauss - C
Cook - C potential B
KP - C potential B
Collingwood E
Bell - D potential C
Read - D
Mahmood - F potential D
Hoggard - C
Harmison - D most of the time, ocassionaly B
Panesar - D potential C

Flintoff - B/A
Vaughan - C
Jones - D potential B
Plunkett - F potential E
Giles - D

You're a harsh teacher i would not like a course with you.

[Langeveldt]

Monty Panesar - E for Extreme

[TT Boy]

England- Current line up

Tres- C-
Strauss- B-
Cook- C/D
KP- C+ (Potential B or higher)
Bell- C/D
Collingwood- D+ (Currently performing above his own station)
Read- D+
Mahmood- F+
Hoggard- C-
Harmison- D- (Once a year a B+)
Panesar- C+

Flintoff- B
Giles- D
G. Jones- D-
S. Jones- C
Plunkett- F
Vaughan- C-

[FRAZ]

Originally Posted by Xuhaib

Just putting on a teachers hat and grading players on their overall skill and potential.

Pakistan

Farhat (B)
Butt (C) potential B+
Hafeez (B)
Younis (A)
Yousuf (A)
Inzi (A)
Faisal (C)
Taufeeq (D)
Akmal (B+) potential A
Afridi and Razzaq (A) in Odi's (C) in tests
Malik (B+)
Shoaib (A)
Asif (A) potential A*
Gul (B) potential A
Rana (B)
Sami (U)
Raza (D) potential A
Hameed (C) potential B
Kaneria (B+) potential A

Edit to A+ please ..
Dont make me mad alright . I am not happy , not happy at all man . You are trying your best to come into my hate crimes listy ......

[Xuhaib]

Originally Posted by FRAZ

Edit to A+ please ..
Dont make me mad alright . I am not happy , not happy at all man . You are trying your best to come into my hate crimes listy ......

Chill out dude. Its my list and i have my own oponions.

[FRAZ]

Originally Posted by Xuhaib

Chill out dude. Its my list and i have my own oponions.

Would youplease change it to A+ please..Please Xuhaib?

[Xuhaib]

Originally Posted by FRAZ

Would youplease change it to A+ please..Please Xuhaib?

Make your own list and give him an A+.

[Swervy]

A+ for me reserved for the all time greats....Shoaib isnt an all time great is he really!!!!

[Langeveldt]

Originally Posted by FRAZ

Edit to A+ please ..
Dont make me mad alright . I am not happy , not happy at all man . You are trying your best to come into my hate crimes listy ......

lol

[Beleg]

Originally Posted by Xuhaib

Just putting on a teachers hat and grading players on their overall skill and potential.

Pakistan

Farhat (B)
Butt (C) potential B+
Hafeez (B)
Younis (A)
Yousuf (A)
Inzi (A)
Faisal (C)
Taufeeq (D)
Akmal (B+) potential A
Afridi and Razzaq (A) in Odi's (C) in tests
Malik (B+)
Shoaib (A)
Asif (A) potential A*
Gul (B) potential A
Rana (B)
Sami (U)
Raza (D) potential A
Hameed (C) potential B
Kaneria (B+) potential A

Farhat - C (potential B)
Butt - C (potential B)
Hafeez - C (potential B)
Younis - B+
Yousuf - B+
Inzy - A
Iqbal - E
Taufeeq - D
Akmal - B
Afridi and Razzaq - B in ODI's with D and C- respectively in tests
Malik - B+ in ODI's and C in tests
Asif - A (potential A)
Shoaib A
Rana - D in tests B in ODI's
Umer Gul - C in tests D in ODI's
Nazir - C in tests
Raza - D (potential B-)
Hameed - D (potential B-)
Kamal - C (potential B)
Kaneria - B-
Sami - off the charts; his sucktitude cannot be graded.
Rao - D

[Tomm NCCC]

Trescothick: C+ currently, could easily be on B+, Pushing for an A
Strauss: B- currently, has every chance of acheiving an A
Cook: B+, A great start to his test career
Pietersen: B, if he can keep his head, and play with a touch more sensiblity, he will be a* in the near future
Collingwood: C+ A few good scores, but needs to become more consistent, and aiming for a B at least
Bell: B, B for bouncebackability. If he carries on the way he has been doing against pakistan, he can turn bouncebackability into acheiveability...
Read: D, seems harsh, but on an international level, he has to redeem himself quick. If he can cement a place in the side, then he can be aiming for a high B
Mahmood: D again, im unconvinced
Hoggard: B-, Having a tough time at the moment but Im sure he'll be coming good soon
Harmison: C-, One good match in the past year. End of term report - Could do much better
Panesar: B, Top class spinner, hard working guy,and has even shown a little quality with the bat but unfortuantely, certain aspects have let him down such as his fielding. Although there is an amount of improvement form him, its the main thing which marrs his game. as soon as this is corrected, we will have an a+ student

[Samuel_Vimes]

For something no one else will dare attempt...European ODI-only nations:

Ireland:

Morgan B-
Porterfield D, potential C
Bray D
N O'Brien C+
Botha C+
Gillespie E
Johnston C+
A White D
McCallan C+
J Mooney D-
Langford-Smith C
Rankin D
K O'Brien E+
Wilson E

Scotland:

Watts D+
Stanger E
Watson C+
Hamilton D
Brown D
Poonia D-
Smith D+
Wright D-
Blain E-
Hoffmann C+
Lyons D+
McCallum E
Nel E
MacRae E
Lockhart D+
Goudie E
Weeraratna E

Netherlands:

Szwarczynski D
de Grooth F
ten Doeschate C+
van Bunge C-
Zuiderent C-
Kervezee C+
de Leede D
van Troost E
Schiferli D-
Stelling F
Kashif E-
Smits D-
Buurman D+
Reekers F
Grandia F
Borren F
Seelaar F