Arjun
Cricketer Of The Year
Raina has done well playing in domestic FC matches averaging 68, but hasn't had much experience facing touring sides or A teams. He's still worth a try.adharcric said:On Raina ~ I think he is ready, he's shown plenty of maturity in this one-day series and although he is only 19, he has plenty of domestic experience unlike Piyush Chawla, who needs more grooming before making the step up. He's young yes, but he's much more experienced than other 19-year old prospects we've seen.
On Bhajji ~ While Powar is a good batsman, Bhajji has done very well as a batsman lately. I know we'd like to think Powar still remains the better batsman overall, but surely "batting" can't be the reason to keep Harbhajan out ... he's been one of our leading batsmen of late.
On Munaf ~ He can definitely blast, but he's far from a "batsman" by the looks of it, really pathetic technique. A potentially dangerous slogger, yes, but I wouldn't count on him consistently resisting good bowling attacks like a Powar, Harbhajan or Kumble can.
Bhajji has just had one good outing with the bat and nothing more. Whatever he can do with the bat, Powar can do better. He has a proven record of scoring over 50 (including a few over 100) from positions eight and nine. The truth is, since the team management (and most fans) don't want two frontline spinners in the side– then again, the conditions in WI don't favour seamers these days– come to think of it, they don't favour any bowler!
As for Munaf, his batting is not as bad as it is made out to be. He may be technically incorrect, but he makes up for that in striking power. There have been stories of how he came in with 4 wickets of his club side down for not too much, then he smashed a century in 40 balls. Even at the first-class level, his chunks at more than a run a ball have bailed his team out of trouble regularly, and have put the bowling side on the back foot quite often. Since he's been picked ahead of Pravin Kumar, with better FC stats this season, and he can bat a bit, it's better to make use of that, not to replace the top seven, but to assist them. He scores a lot quicker than Kumble and has a technique better than Harbhajan and far better than VR Singh, whose bizarre slogs have often boosted his team's totals.
I'm talking of this combination-
- Sehwag
- Gambhir
- Dravid
- Raina
- Yuvraj
- Dhoni
- Irfan
- Munaf/Pravin Kumar
- Powar/Harbhajan
- Kumble
- Sreesnath
Last edited: