• Welcome to the Cricket Web forums, one of the biggest forums in the world dedicated to cricket.

    You are currently viewing our boards as a guest which gives you limited access to view most discussions and access our other features. By joining our free community you will have access to post topics, respond to polls, upload content and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free so please, join the Cricket Web community today!

    If you have any problems with the registration process or your account login, please contact us.

Indian ODI team discussion thread

Arjun

Cricketer Of The Year
Every India supporter has issues regarding the ODI side. There's a problem too many. They could do with a few big changes. There are a few good things to build on. You can discuss all of them here, in this Indian ODI team discussion thread, rather than clog official threads or start a barrage of new ones. Go on. Let rip.
 

Arjun

Cricketer Of The Year
The selection theme has been overdone, so let's look at something different. The Indians will be facing the Kiwis in a triangular in Zimbabwe, so here's a plan to face the Kiwi bowlers-
  • Bond- Be careful. Don't lose wickets against him. Rotate the strike, look for singles but if he's had an off day, take a risk...
  • Oram- Smash him around the park. Bludgeon what he offers. Set a benchmark of five sixes off his bowling. In a few words, show no mercy.
  • Cairns- Watch for movement. Play with a straight bat. Run the singles, but there's always the odd buffet ball.
  • Vettori- On a tough day, take lots of singles. Don't lose a wicket against him.
  • Styris- One more target. Run lots of singles and hit the buffet ball hard.
 

Jamee999

Hall of Fame Member
My team for India ODIs:

Sehwag
Tendulkar
Mongia+/Pathan
Laxman
Dravid(1st innings)/Ganguly(2nd)
Ganguly(1st)/Dravid(2nd)
Pathan/Mongia+
Agarkar
Kumble
Harbhajan
Khan

If one of Sehwag/Sachin gets out early send in Mongia, with a more solid technique, but still able to take advantage of the restrictions.

If they don't, and make a big partnership send in Pathan who can slog at it till he gets in, and slot Mongia in at 7.

Dravid can play as a finisher at 6 if chasing, and can play as an orthodox No.5 if batting first.
 

tooextracool

International Coach
they really need to do something about their pace bowlers, almost all of them are useless.
and dhoni isnt anything other than very poor if you ask me, how in the world he manages to score runs sometimes i'll never know.
 

Sanz

Hall of Fame Member
Arjun said:
Every India supporter has issues regarding the ODI side.
When did I appointed you as my spokesperson ?

Oh and so much for your support for Nehra in the other thread, He is out of your team despite taking six wickets. :laugh: and Irfan is in as an allrounder. :-O
 

honestbharani

Whatever it takes!!!
Sehwag
Sachin
Kaif
Mongia/Sriram/Badani/Rao (trust me, I think they will do good, any of these 3)
Dravid
Yuvraj
Kaarthick (no more Indian Gilchrist, PLEASE)
Pathan
Harbhajan
two out of (Nehra, Zaheer, Balaji, Agarkar, Kumble)



And if India really want to play 5 bowlers, play Agarkar, Pathan and either Zaheer or Balaji or Nehra as the third bowler and two spinners and remove Badani/Sriram/Mongia.
 

Sanz

Hall of Fame Member
Sehwag
Sachin,
Kaif,
Yuvraj,
Dravid(W/K and Captain),
Sriram,
Mongia/JPYadav,
Pathan,
Balaji,
Agarkar
Harbhajan
 

Arjun

Cricketer Of The Year
Jameee999 said:
If one of Sehwag/Sachin gets out early send in Mongia, with a more solid technique, but still able to take advantage of the restrictions.

If they don't, and make a big partnership send in Pathan who can slog at it till he gets in, and slot Mongia in at 7.
Mongia? You mean Dinesh Mongia? We're talking ODI's here. There's no way he'd fit in one. He's got a dreadful strike rate and hasn't converted his scratchy starts into big scores- a certain ODI misfit has six scores over 100, while Dinesh only has 3 over 50!
honestbharani said:
Kaarthick (no more Indian Gilchrist, PLEASE)
Name one man better than Dhoni. Kaarthick? He can't hit the ball!
 

Arjun

Cricketer Of The Year
tooextracool said:
they really need to do something about their pace bowlers, almost all of them are useless.
and dhoni isnt anything other than very poor if you ask me, how in the world he manages to score runs sometimes i'll never know.
You mention pace bowlers, but can you name any with real pace? That's always been a problem, even when they play three seamers abroad. They're all seam/swing bowlers and once the batsmen get set, it's easy to get set against them. Little wonder then, that they're at the bottom of the ODI table. If you look at the top pace attacks in international cricket in the recent past, there is at least one tearaway pacer in every attack.
 

Arjun

Cricketer Of The Year
A plan for the SL batsmen-
  • Sanath- NEVER bowl short and wide. Bowl straight and move the ball a little either way. If one has pace, blast him.
  • Marvan- Set fields in his stronger scoring areas and cut out the singles. Power pacers can blast him too.
  • Sangakkara- Likes the ball coming on the bat. Bowl straight, and use a few variations. Spinners can attack him.
  • Mahela- Bowl straight.
  • Dilshan- He has this tendency of running on a point fielder's arm. Have your best man there and set up a run-out.
  • Arnold- Attack him with a strike seamer, bowling into him.
  • Chandana- Attack. Don't give him chances to run singles.
  • Vaas- Bowl straight.
  • Tailenders- Do the basic stuff right.
 

Arjun

Cricketer Of The Year
Again, fans have done the obvious thing- post a selection. Let's have something different, shall we? Even if you make a selection, make it very different from the official ones, won't you?

Now, Kumble's role in the ODI side is in doubt. The final in Colombo may just have signalled his exit from ODI's, so you can start looking for a new contender- not just as a fill-in for Harbhajan, but also as a partner. Let's look at these options-
  • Vidyut- More or less the best choice not just as Harbhajan's reserve, but also his partner. Rush him in!!!
  • Amit Mishra- Not the ideal choice in ODI's since he's a leggie who likes to turn the ball and looks for wickets, so he may go for more than a few runs. However, if used well, he can be quite a handful. He's a better batsman and fielder than Kumble and Karthik.
  • Rajesh Pawar- The dark horse in the race, Pawar has moved up from being an extra in the Mumbai side to Baroda's frontliner. He's not got a spectacular OD average, but he's done well in the latest Ranji season and he got the selectors' attention with his batting and fielding.
  • Ramesh Powar- Disappointing OD figures, but his performance in FC matches is very good.
Take your pick. Ideal choices would be Vidyut in the XI and Mishra as reserve.
 

tooextracool

International Coach
Arjun said:
You mention pace bowlers, but can you name any with real pace? That's always been a problem, even when they play three seamers abroad. They're all seam/swing bowlers and once the batsmen get set, it's easy to get set against them. Little wonder then, that they're at the bottom of the ODI table. If you look at the top pace attacks in international cricket in the recent past, there is at least one tearaway pacer in every attack.
true, india really havent had too many really quick bowlers. srinath was relatively quick when he first burst on to the scene, but whatever pace he had was compensated by his lack of accuracy and his tendency to bowl too short. zaheer khan too had a bit off pace when he first came on, but he was just rubbish and injuries have only made him worse. they certainly havent had anyone who could bowl at 90+ mph perhaps ever.
 

Arjun

Cricketer Of The Year
Comments on this selection?
  • Sehwag (inner-ring catching)
  • Gambhir (outfield)
  • Kaif (cover)
  • Yuvraj (point)
  • Dhoni (WK)
  • Dravid (C, slip)
  • JP Yadav (vc, RM-new ball, outfield)
  • Vidyut (SLA, ???)/Bangar (RMF- change, inner-ring)
  • Harbhajan (OB, outfield)
  • Zaheer (LFM-new, outfield)/VR Singh (RFM-new, ???)
  • Nehra (LFM-change, inner-ring run-out)
 

Arjun

Cricketer Of The Year
tooextracool said:
true, india really havent had too many really quick bowlers. srinath was relatively quick when he first burst on to the scene, but whatever pace he had was compensated by his lack of accuracy and his tendency to bowl too short. zaheer khan too had a bit off pace when he first came on, but he was just rubbish and injuries have only made him worse. they certainly havent had anyone who could bowl at 90+ mph perhaps ever.
With all these new experts, they can retrieve lost pace in this attack. Zaheer and Nehra were bowling in the 140's for the later part of 2002, particularly in England, SL and India. Nehra let one loose at 139 in the IndianOil Cup final, so he's getting some of it back. There is VR Singh of Punjab and Abid Nabi of unfancied J&K who are supposed to be fast if you believe these reporters, who watch more domestic matches than those five unwise clowns who pick the same team time and again. There may be many more, but the doors have to be open and they need all the support of the people in charge.
 

honestbharani

Whatever it takes!!!
Arjun said:
Mongia? You mean Dinesh Mongia? We're talking ODI's here. There's no way he'd fit in one. He's got a dreadful strike rate and hasn't converted his scratchy starts into big scores- a certain ODI misfit has six scores over 100, while Dinesh only has 3 over 50!Name one man better than Dhoni. Kaarthick? He can't hit the ball!
As indicated by his 93 under pressure against Pak?
 

honestbharani

Whatever it takes!!!
Arjun said:
Comments on this selection?
  • Sehwag (inner-ring catching)
  • Gambhir (outfield)
  • Kaif (cover)
  • Yuvraj (point)
  • Dhoni (WK)
  • Dravid (C, slip)
  • JP Yadav (vc, RM-new ball, outfield)
  • Vidyut (SLA, ???)/Bangar (RMF- change, inner-ring)
  • Harbhajan (OB, outfield)
  • Zaheer (LFM-new, outfield)/VR Singh (RFM-new, ???)
  • Nehra (LFM-change, inner-ring run-out)
Dhoni is no good as a batsman in ODIs. Forget his bad keeping, he cannot even merit any arguments for his batting. He cannot play quickish spin and doesn't have shots around the ground. He scores in the V and that is not good enough in any form of the game these days. He struggles when he has a few overs to go and is asked to play himself in.
 

ramkumar_gr

U19 Vice-Captain
My Team

Sachin
Sehwag
Ganguly
Dravid
Yuvraj
Sriram/Badani/Venugopala Rao/Vidyut
JP Yadav
Dinesh Kaarthick
Pathan
R P Singh
Harbajan Singh

Comments please!!!!
 

ramkumar_gr

U19 Vice-Captain
ramkumar_gr said:
Sachin
Sehwag
Ganguly
Dravid
Yuvraj
Sriram/Badani/Venugopala Rao/Vidyut
JP Yadav
Dinesh Kaarthick
Pathan
R P Singh
Harbajan Singh

Comments please!!!!
I have got 6 specialist batsmen, and an allrounder at no. 7, more than a decent wicketkeeper batsman at no. 8 and 3 bowlers.
JP Yadav is my fourth bowler, as i go by the domestic statistics. He definitely is a decent bat.
The other 10 overs would be shared by Sehwag,Sachin and Sriram/Badani/Venugopala Rao/Vidyut and of course Vidyut is the best bowling option of the 4.

The best thing i have done is i have not included Kaif, who for me , is someone who has no credentials to be part of this Indian batting line up.
 

Top