who is that jason ?
Of course its Vinoo Mankad !! I am not sure about the peculiarity WRT the name. But his real name was Mulvantrai Himmatlal Mankad, Vinoo being his schoolboy nick name IIRC.
SJS is that the peculiarity ?
Last edited by JASON; 12-11-2004 at 04:39 AM.
wats so pecuilar about his name? except the "maknading" rule?!Originally Posted by JASON
i dont think people should be banned if they come up with an answer, and a decent reason why.... i mean, both my guesses fitted the bill.... in a way, tis slightly ambigious, and for that reason, if the answer supplied fits the question, it shld not be reason for banning.
if it was a wild stab, yes, if not, no
was the mankad named after him ?
CRICKET QUESTION # 1 A cricketing great, there is something peculiar about my name ? Who am I and whats the peculiarity about my name.
Q1 Is he a great Batsman from the past ? YES
Q2 Did he play for a southern hemisphere team? ....NO
Q3 Did he play international cricket for England?....NO
Q4 Is he from the subcontinent?....YES
Q5. Is he from India? ... YES
Q6: Did he ever open the innings for India?....YES
Q7 is it Farokh Engineer...NO
Q8 is his name peculiar because he was actually an engineer...No (naturally)
Q 9 Did he play for Karnataka in Ranji Trophy....NO
Q 10 Was his career cut short by a Charlie Griffith delivery resulting in life threatening head injury and requiring multiple surgery ?......NO
FIRST HINT : He was from Bombay.
Q11 Is the peculiarity about his name to do with a girl's name (his first name I mean)?…..NO
Q12 Did he score 65 and 67 no on debut (in Tests) ?....NO
Q 13 Was the peculiarity with the name to do with a world famous musician?....NO
Q14 and Q15 : am i vijay merchant? for the following reason?
Like when Marathi novelist N.S. Phadke happened to meet Vijay Merchant around the time Kamalatai Phadke was expecting. Phadke reportedly said to Merchant, "During the coming Kanpur test if I get a don and you score a double century, I’II name him Vijay."
The rest was naming history: The Phadke household got a son, Vijay Merchant did score a double century, and Kamalatai’s son did get named Vijay. ….NO( Answering your post in totality)
SECOND HINT : Part of the last answer is correct
Q16. did he make his Test debut agaist England at Lords in 1946 ?...YES
Q17. did he average 71.64 in his first class career…..YESOriginally Posted by bryce
Q18. and 19. i know! i'm sunil gavaskar! (y)….NO(You are not and u r definitely banned )
ONLY ONE TURN LEFT After one more query we need the complete answer !!
PS BRYCE You didnt run away fast enough that last time
Last edited by SJS; 12-11-2004 at 04:45 AM.
i'm confused you said 'yes' that he made his test debut in 1946 at lords(vinoo mankad) and you said 'yes' to him also averaging 71.64 in first class cricket(vijay merchant), since merchant made his test debut in 1933/34 and mankad averaged about half that in first class cricket i don't know what to think.....
Bryce I think I'm banned from this question now for making a wrong answer!! Your answer is probably the correct one!!Originally Posted by bryce
Q20. was the mankad named after him ?..NOOriginally Posted by SJS
Plus you guys made another guess at Mankad. But we will forget that. Any one wants anothe try before we go into the tie breaker ??
STUPID STUPID ME !!
Old age is catching up. Or its my dogs bothering me to take them for their evening walk. Whatever !!
No he did not make his debut at Lords in 1946.
Yes it was Merchant. I am too far for you guys ton hurl your laptops at me.
So why dont you just go ahead and tell what was peculiar about his name
Last edited by SJS; 12-11-2004 at 04:53 AM.
lol@jasonOriginally Posted by JASON
Was it because Vijay Merchant's real name is Vijay Thackersey
we've established it wasn't merchant....he also debuted in the wrong year etc.
it can't be just that after 20 queries
Read SJS's Post above !!Originally Posted by deeps
YESSSOriginally Posted by JASON
I sneak out from the rear doors with my labradors.
BTW, do you know why he was called Merchant and not Thackersey ?
I wont blame you foor not answering nor ban you for giving wrong answers which I couldnt tell from right ones anyway
There are currently 2 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 2 guests)