Should Ricky Ponting cop a ban?

[GIMH]

I know two wrongs do not make a right and all that, but has Broad ever copped a suspension? I genuinely don't know, I'm just asking.. if he hasn't got one yet, Ponting shouldn't either.

GTFO, Broad may have been a brat but he has never done anything comparable

[vcs]

GTFO, Broad may have been a brat but he has never done anything comparable

You could be right, I haven't seen the Ponting incident.

[Oscillatingmind]

Ponting misses a game, Siddle gets fined, I wouldn't be unhappy with that response, He's just thoroughly embarrassed himself and be extension he team.

[Bun]

I knowo wrongs do not make a right and all that, but has Broad ever copped a suspension? I genuinely don't know, I'm just asking.. if he hasn't got one yet, Ponting shouldn't either.

Preteen Girls are different from men.

[GIMH]

You could be right, I haven't seen the Ponting incident.

Fair enough mate...believe me it was much worse than Sir Stuey has ever done

[Spikey]

It depends what he said.

He called KP a monkey. No idea what he said to the ump though




too soon to make jokes about 'that'?

[GIMH]

[Black_Warrior]

Ponting should be banned straightaway. Bill Lawrie came the closest to calling it what it was...rest played it safe and diplomatic... but it is this sort of behaviour that allows Ponting to behave like that on the field and get away with it. He has done this before..pointing fingers and getting away..and he will most likely get away this time aswell

[Black_Warrior]

GTFO, Broad may have been a brat but he has never done anything comparable

I havent seen Broad behave like that with an umpire. Throwing the ball at a batsman is quite bad..but behaving like that with an umpire takes it to a new level

[GIMH]

I sadly think that Brumby's prediction is not cynical but not pragmatic. In relation to the series outcome, obviously Ponting is the kind of player who can turn it round anytime but I'm not remotely worried about whether he does or does not play at Sydney. I just think he shouldn't be allowed to play there.

[Craig]

If Ponting is suspended, can CA appeal it, or is the decision final?

[Spikey]

If Ponting is suspended, can CA appeal it, or is the decision final?

"We're going home if you don't overturn it"

[Son Of Coco]

I voted fine & suspension...but I only really went for the suspension so we could get a new face in for Sydney.

[Burgey]

"We're going home if you don't overturn it"

I lol'ed.

[Cevno]

Chris Broad is not the match referee ,so he could get a ban this time.

Though will that be a bad thing for Australia,i am not sure.