Player Ratings - As We Go By...

[Jono]

You miss me in Melbourne, admit it

 

[morgieb]

You miss me in Melbourne, admit it

Yeah, one less person to throw eggs at....

 

[Goughy]

Watson: 5
Katich: 6
Ponting: 6
Clarke:3
Hussey: 9
North: 4
Haddin: 8
Johnson: 2
Doherty: 3
Hilfenhaus: 4
Siddle: 8

Strauss: 8
Cook: 9
Trott: 8
Pietersen: 6
Collingwood: 4
Bell: 7
Prior: 5
Broad: 4
Swann: 4
Anderson: 6
Finn: 7

 

[benchmark00]

Hmm, I don't recall making this thread. Though I did have a big weekend...

 

[pasag]

You miss me in Melbourne, admit it

When are you back?

 

[Uppercut]

Watson- 6
Katich- 5
Ponting- 6
Clarke- 2
Hussey- 9
North- 4
Haddin- 8
Johnson- lol
Doherty- 3
Siddle- 8
Hilfenhaus- 4

Strauss- 8
Cook- 9
Trott- 8
Pietersen- 6
Collingwood- 2
Bell- 7
Prior- 4
Broad- 4
Swann- 4
Anderson- 7
Finn- 7

 

[Howe_zat]

Broad was better than Prior, Swann and Hilfy tbf.

Katich was equal to or better than KP.

 

[straw man]

Crims

Twatto 6
Katich 5
Chimpy 6.5
Clarke 3
Hussey 9
North 2
Haddin 8
Johnson 10
Doherty 4
Siddle 8
Hilfenhaus 4

Nothing like a bit of childish name-calling and baiting to get things going

 

[Spark]

KP getting more than Katich a bit odd.

 

[GIMH]

Hardly baiting is it

 

[GIMH]

KP getting more than Katich a bit odd.

Katich failed second dig

 

[Howe_zat]

Katich failed second dig

After having been in the field fr no reward for two days, sent in to bat with nothing to gain and fell to a good ball. Still got 50 in the 1st dig. Equal to KP imo.

 

[Faisal1985]

Watson: 6
Katich: 6
Ponting: 6
Clarke: N/A due to fitness issues
Hussey: 10
North: 2
Haddin: 8
Johnson: 1
Doherty: 4.5
Hilfenhaus: 3
Siddle: 8

Strauss: 7.5
Cook: 10
Trott: 7.5
Pietersen: 6
Collingwood: 3
Bell: 7
Prior: 5
Broad: 2
Swann: 5
Anderson: 7.5
Finn: 5.5

Yeah would tend to agree with those numbers...

 

[GIMH]

I only had half a point between them tbf.

 

[Uppercut]

Katich was equal to or better than KP.

How?

 

[vic_orthdox]

Hmm, I don't recall making this thread. Though I did have a big weekend...

Just moved a few posts out of the First Test thread. Be nice to keep these all together as we go along, rather than lose it in the big threads.

 

[TumTum]

Domestic youngsters in with a chance to play this series ratings:
P.Hughes - 4
S.Smith - 2
U.Khawaja - 2
M.Marsh - 0 (utter ****ing failure)
J.Hazlewood - 0 (gone missing)
J.Pattinson - 0 (gone missing)
C.Ferguson - 6 (looked impressive but can't convert)

 

[vic_orthdox]

Hazlewood, Pattinson and (especially) Marsh were never a chance of playing in the series.

 

[benchmark00]

Domestic youngsters in with a chance to play this series ratings:
P.Hughes - 4
S.Smith - 2
U.Khawaja - 2
M.Marsh - 0 (utter ****ing failure)
J.Hazlewood - 0 (gone missing)
J.Pattinson - 0 (gone missing)
C.Ferguson - 6 (looked impressive but can't convert)

What are you basing these ratings on?

Their performances in the Master Chef kitchen or what?

 

[TumTum]

What are you basing these ratings on?

Their performances in the Master Chef kitchen or what?

First class matches primarily and a bit from the other formats.