I'll have a go at the alltime craziness too
G.Chappell (or maybe Ponting or Mcabe, hard to split)
Border or S.Waugh (fencesitting again)
Davidson (think he'd offer more balance to an attack than Lindwill who was similar to Lillee)
McGrath (thought about Spofforth, went for what I know)
I know far less about old school English cricket than Australian, so I may have made some bad calls; possibly Barnes in for one of the middle order to strengthen the bowling.