noticed three i disagree with but otherwise they are all very good suggestions..
*Giles' original batting rating is realistic
*Symonds should stay a batsman and not become an allrounder(because that's what he is IRL)
*Kyle Mills should stay an allrounder(even though his batting ability does need to be decreased)
also try and add suggestions in regards to aggressive/defensive levels, i.e:Gilchrist should be changed to very aggressive
i will try to list some if i find time
ODI XI to match the best
To answer your question, yes
METEORIC RISE ?