I don't debate cricket with you #neverwrong #nevergivesground
Ftr, I don't think its unreasonable to think MacGill could have/would have been better than Kumble. But you don't just discard his series in 2003/04 because its against India, that's crazy talk.
Its a shame MacGill never got to play in India. His record in SL isn't great, but he only played 2 tests there and he did okay in one test.