Yeah well the debate about Tsolekile is around Tests
No way I'd have him in the ODI team, I'd value a batting keeper over his glovework and a 21 average any day. Don't really mind ABDV keeping in ODIs, but in Tests I reckon we need a genuine gloveman at 7.
People say it'll take away from our batting but tbh we shouldn't need to rely on a specialist number 7 when history dictates a top 6 and a specialist keeper is fine, and when we have Amla, Kallis, de Villiers beefing up the middle order (fair to say the best top/middle order in the world atm?).