Originally Posted by kingkallis
To be honest, both.
Malcolm Marshall is usually a 1st round pick when it comes to test matches but he was left alone for several rounds in ODIs. Same goes some other notables ones like Steyn.
I agree he is not a first round ODI pick. Even I got him in 4th round. His stats may be not as good as others, but was he really bad in ODIs? From what I can say, many modern batsmen who have made most runs in flat pitches against poor bowling attacks should still find it tough against a quality bowler like him, right?
And what is your opinion on Holding? He did win two World Cups...